Lion Air: Some Are Looking Where To Place The Blame, Others Wonder If Their Pilot Can Fly Their Plane

The passengers on the Lion Air 610 flight were on board one of Boeing's newest, most advanced planes.

The pilot and co-pilot of the 737 MAX 8 were more than experienced, with around 11,000 flying hours between them.
The weather conditions were not an issue and the flight was routine.
So what caused that plane to crash into the Java Sea just 13 minutes after takeoff?
Lion Air victim's family files suit against Boeing
Lion Air victim's family files suit against Boeing
More than two weeks after the catastrophe, investigators are still piecing together the clues.
As they do, the focus has turned to Boeing, which allegedly failed to tell pilots about a new system feature implicated in the crash — information that aviation analysts say could have possibly saved the lives of all 189 people on board.
A lawsuit against Boeing related to the crash was filed Thursday. The parents of one passenger sued the company, claiming that the downed plane, a 737 MAX 8, had an unsafe design. The suit alleges Boeing failed to communicate a new safety feature that hadn't existed in previous 737s.
Lion Air's operational director has accused Boeing of withholding information from pilots in the manuals about a safety feature that automatically lowers the airplane's nose to prevent or exit a stall.
Boeing Chief Executive Dennis Muilenburg told Fox Business Network on Tuesday that information was available as part of the training manual.
On Wednesday, a Boeing spokesperson said in an email that the company could not "discuss specifics of an ongoing investigation" and that the company had "provided two updates for our operators around the world that re-emphasize existing procedures for these situations."
"We are confident in the safety of the 737 MAX. Safety remains our top priority and is a core value for everyone at Boeing," the spokesperson said.
CNN has spoken to nine aviation experts, including pilots who fly the 737 MAX 8 planes, about the crash. While they all emphasized that only a complete investigation will give a full picture of what actually happened in the cockpit that morning, all have concluded that, in one way or another, Boeing's actions fell short — leaving not only the families of the victims shaken, but also the aviation industry.
Boeing declined to comment for this article, referring CNN to its most recent statement cited above.
A wallet is seen in the water where the plane went down.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
A wallet is seen in the water where the plane went down.
Hide Caption
14 of 27
A relative of a passenger cries at a hospital in Jakarta.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
A relative of a passenger cries at a hospital in Jakarta.
Hide Caption
15 of 27
President Widodo (front row, second from right) tours the operations center in Jakarta where debris is laid out.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
President Widodo (front row, second from right) tours the operations center in Jakarta where debris is laid out.
Hide Caption
16 of 27
Police work to identify personal belongings that are believed to be from the plane's wreckage.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
Police work to identify personal belongings that are believed to be from the plane's wreckage.
Hide Caption
17 of 27
A police officer studies a map in the search-and-rescue command center.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
A police officer studies a map in the search-and-rescue command center.
Hide Caption
18 of 27
A diver with the Indonesian Navy enters the water off the north coast of Karawang.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
A diver with the Indonesian Navy enters the water off the north coast of Karawang.
Hide Caption
19 of 27
Rescue workers carry a body that was recovered from the waters near Jakarta on October 29.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
Rescue workers carry a body that was recovered from the waters near Jakarta on October 29.
Hide Caption
20 of 27
A woman in Pangkal Pinang prays as she and others wait for news on October 29.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
A woman in Pangkal Pinang prays as she and others wait for news on October 29.
Hide Caption
21 of 27
People gather on the beach as a rescue team prepares to leave the coast of Karawang.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
People gather on the beach as a rescue team prepares to leave the coast of Karawang.
Hide Caption
22 of 27
Wreckage from the plane lies at a port in Jakarta.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
Wreckage from the plane lies at a port in Jakarta.
Hide Caption
23 of 27
Bagus Sunjoyo, head of airport authority for Soekarno-Hatta International Airport, speaks to members of the media during a news conference.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
Bagus Sunjoyo, head of airport authority for Soekarno-Hatta International Airport, speaks to members of the media during a news conference.
Hide Caption
24 of 27
People watch a rescue team as a helicopter flies overhead.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
People watch a rescue team as a helicopter flies overhead.
Hide Caption
25 of 27
People look at the passenger manifest for Lion Air Flight JT 610.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
People look at the passenger manifest for Lion Air Flight JT 610.
Hide Caption
26 of 27
Merdiana Harahap is consoled in Medan, Indonesia. Her husband was on the plane.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
Merdiana Harahap is consoled in Medan, Indonesia. Her husband was on the plane.
Hide Caption
27 of 27
A relative of one of the crash victims tosses flower petals from an Indonesian Navy ship on Tuesday, November 6.
Photos: In photos: Lion Air plane crashes off Indonesia
A relative of one of the crash victims tosses flower petals from an Indonesian Navy ship on Tuesday, November 6.
In recent years, Lion Air, the popular Indonesian budget carrier, had given itself a makeover.
The privately owned carrier was the first airline to put Boeing's 737 MAX 8 — a more efficient and environmentally friendly upgrade of a jet introduced in 1967 — into service. According to Boeing, the Max jets are said to be 10% to 12% more efficient than their predecessors.
In 2011, Lion Air announced a $21.7 billion order for 230 of the single-aisle, twin-engine jets — the largest single order for commercial jets in its history at the time, according to Boeing.
Lion Air became the first airline to put the 737 MAX 8 into service, and later started buying more versions — the 9 and larger 10 in a $6.24 billion deal this year.
Those upgrades may have signaled a bid by Lion Air to rectify its spotty safety record over the last decade, including a 2013 non-fatal crash and a ban from European and US airspace between 2007 and 2016.
Boeing stumbles as investors worry it could be liable for Lion Air crash
Boeing stumbles as investors worry it could be liable for Lion Air crash
The European and US bans have since been lifted, with the international civil aviation organization giving the airline its top rating in terms of safety this year. The MAX 8s have been a visible part of that boost.
But with any new fleet, pilots must undergo additional training.
"Generally speaking, when there is a new delivery of aircraft — even though they are the same family — airline operators are required to send their pilots for training," Bijan Vasigh, professor of economics and finance at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University, told CNN.
Those training sessions generally take only a few days, but they give the pilots time to familiarize themselves with any new features or changes to the system, Vasigh said.
One of the MAX 8's new features is an anti-stalling device, the maneuvering characteristics augmentation system (MCAS). If the MCAS detects that the plane is flying too slowly or steeply, and at risk of stalling, it can automatically lower the airplane's nose.
It's meant to be a safety mechanism. But the problem, according to Lion Air and a growing chorus of international pilots, was that no one knew about that system.
Zwingli Silalahi, Lion Air's operational director, said that Boeing did not suggest additional training for pilots operating the 737 MAX 8. "We didn't receive any information from Boeing or from regulator about that additional training for our pilots," Zwingli told CNN Wednesday.
"We don't have that in the manual of the Boeing 737 MAX 8. That's why we don't have the special training for that specific situation," he said.
Investigators are examining whether an angle of attack (AOA) sensor on the outside of the Lion Air plane transmitted incorrect data that could have triggered the MCAS to force the plane's nose down.
An AOA sensor is an instrument, similar to a small wind vane, that sits outside the plane just below the cockpit and sends information to its computers about the angle of the plane's nose relative to the oncoming air. The sensor helps to determine whether the plane is about to stall and dive.
Investigators said that the day before the crash, the jet experienced problems with its AOA sensor, which was replaced. The last four flights — including, crucially, the flight that crashed, according to Soerjanto Tjahjono, the head of Indonesia's National Transportation Safety Committee (KNKT), also had problems.
On Wednesday, the Wall Street Journal reported that Southwest Airlines, a US carrier that also has a fleet of MAX 8 planes, replaced two malfunctioning AOA sensors, during the three weeks before the Lion Air crash.
CNN has asked Boeing for a copy of the original manuals issued to carriers who bought the Boeing 737 MAX 8. Boeing has not provided those operation manuals to CNN. Representatives from American, United and Southwest airlines have all told CNN that Boeing did not include information in its Flight Crew Operations Manual that explained the functions of the new feature.
Lion Air's flight manual did not contain information about the new system, according to Reuters, which has seen the manual.
CNN has reviewed updated guidance issued by Boeing on November 6, and a subsequent Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) emergency directive that reinforced Boeing's update on November 7.